Eleuthera is a 110-mile stretch of unspoiled beauty, where pink sand beaches meet turquoise waters and charming, brightly colored Bahamian architecture dots the landscape. With its laid-back vibe and stunning natural wonders, it’s a paradise worth exploring.
This 3-day Eleuthera itinerary is perfect for travelers who want to experience the island from north to south. By staying in the middle of the island, you’ll maximize your driving time and easily reach the highlights in all directions.
The quaint, historic town of Governor’s Harbour makes an ideal base. Here you’ll find self-catering accommodations, grocery and liquor stores, and great dining options.
Day 1: Central Eleuthera – Governor’s Harbour & Surrounds
Morning / Breakfast
-
Squires Village Coffee & Gift Shop: Start your day with the best coffee on the island—freshly brewed using an authentic Italian espresso machine. Sip a hot or iced cappuccino, latte, or espresso, and pair it with a fresh breakfast sandwich. Don’t miss the attached gift shop for unique finds. MAP
-
After breakfast, take a stroll down to the harbor, admire the historic Haynes Library, and explore some local charm of Cupid’s Cay.
Morning & Afternoon
-
French Leave Beach: Just minutes from town, this mile-long pink sand beach is perfect for swimming, snorkeling, or long walks. It’s rarely crowded, and you’ll often find a quiet spot all to yourself.
-
Tip: Bring your own beach chairs, umbrellas, and coolers. Many accommodations provide these—check before heading out.
-
-
If easterly winds are blowing, skip French Leave and head to the calm “Caribbean side.” Try Ten Bay Beach or Alabaster Bay, both 15 minutes from town. These shallow, calm beaches are ideal for small children or relaxed floating.
-
Optional stop: The Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve, a peaceful garden showcasing Eleuthera’s native flora.
Evening
-
Dinner in Governor’s Harbour:
-
Try Tippy’s for a beachfront setting and fresh seafood.
-
Or opt for The Buccaneer Club, a local favorite with Bahamian dishes and casual options like burgers.
-
-
Friday night special: If you’re here on a Friday, don’t miss Fish Fry Friday—a lively street party with music, dancing, conch salad, and local Bahamian fried fish.
Day 2: North Eleuthera – Beaches, Blue Holes & Bridges
Morning / Breakfast
-
Grab a takeaway coffee and breakfast from Squires Village—today is a road trip day!
-
Drive about 40 minutes north.
Stops Along the Way
-
Gaulding Cay Beach: A beautiful cove with calm waters.
-
Queen’s Baths: Natural rock pools where you can dip on calm days. Caution: Stay back if seas are rough.
-
Blow Hole (near Glass Window): Keep an eye out on your left for this natural ocean spout.
-
Glass Window Bridge: One of Eleuthera’s most iconic sights—the deep blue Atlantic on one side, and the turquoise Bight of Eleuthera on the other.
-
Preacher’s Cave: A historic cave where the Eleutheran Adventurers first landed. Stroll down to the adjacent beach, one of the most beautiful on the island.
-
Sapphire Blue Hole: A deep ocean hole where adventurous travelers can jump in for a refreshing swim. Tip: Don’t wear sunscreen or bug spray to protect this fragile site.
Afternoon / Lunch
-
Head to Gene’s Dock and catch the ferry to Spanish Wells.
-
Rent a golf cart to explore this quaint fishing town.
-
Stop for lunch at Wreckers or Sandbar Restaurant on Russell Island.
Evening
-
Return to Governor’s Harbour before sunset—driving at night is challenging.
-
End the day with a sundowner cocktail at 1648 Restaurant, then enjoy dinner at your accommodation (consider hiring a private chef!).
Day 3: South Eleuthera – Caves, Bays & Local Charm
Morning
-
Have a light breakfast at home or grab a sandwich from Squires Village.
-
Drive about 35 minutes south to Winding Bay. Snorkel the reef—if you’re lucky, you may spot sea turtles.
- The Cut is situated in the cove next to Winding Bay and is an interesting place for a swim
Midday
-
Continue south to Rock Sound:
-
Explore the cool Cathedral Caves.
-
Visit the Ocean Hole, a deep blue inland lagoon full of fish (swimming allowed, but no fishing).
-
Lunch
-
Enjoy lunch at The Wild Orchid in Rock Sound, known for fresh flavors and a great view.
Afternoon
-
Stop at Tarpum Bay, a photogenic village with colorful Bahamian architecture.
-
Meet local fishermen at the dock and check out the day’s catch—sometimes lobster or conch in season.
-
Take a photo at the famous swings in the ocean.
Evening
-
Grill fresh seafood at your accommodation, or head back to The Buccaneer Club, which often features live music on Tuesdays.
Tips for Visiting Eleuthera
-
Best time to visit: November to May for dry, sunny weather.
-
Getting around: Renting a car is essential.
-
What to pack:
-
Reef-safe sunscreen
-
Water shoes for rocky areas
-
Insect repellent
-
Light, long clothing for evenings
-
Where to Stay in Governor’s Harbour
-
Squires Estate: Historic houses, cottages, and apartments on the hill.
-
Cigatoo Resort: Stylish, modern apartments in town.
-
Vacation rentals & Airbnbs: Wide range for all budgets.
Conclusion
In just 3 days, you can experience Eleuthera’s pink sand beaches, dramatic cliffs, charming towns, and hidden gems. Staying in Governor’s Harbour makes it easy to explore north and south while enjoying great dining and accommodation options.
From snorkeling with turtles to dancing at Fish Fry Friday, Eleuthera offers memories that last a lifetime.
